Kim Martucci's Blog

Kim is so in love with the science of meteorology that her number one hobby is chasing tornadoes. On her most exciting excursion into tornado alley, she spotted twelve of the dangerous storms. The story she broadcast about that trip helped earn her an Emmy Award nomination as best weathercaster in New England.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

TORTUOUS SLAUGHTERHOUSES

I eat meat.

Thinking about how that cute cow goes from the pasture (if it was *even* lucky enough to graze in one) to my dinner table is something I don’t like to give much thought to. I’m sure I am like a lot of you – If you don’t hear about atrocities, it is easy live by the mantra “out of sight is out of mind.” I fight the battle of wanting to know, but not wanting to be so disturbed that the thought of torture plagues my mind all day. I feel lazy, guilty.

Let me back up for a moment. There are SO MANY more atrocities that take place on a daily basis, that I set myself up for backlash for not, perhaps, pointing them out first. I sometimes feel like it is a crime to show emotion about animal abuse without first showing the same amount of emotion about human abuse. The people who make me feel this way have a valid point in that there are multitudes of horrible acts being committed every day worthy of outrage. However, just because I am using the sad example of torture at a slaughterhouse as my sounding board, please don’t mistake me for not caring for the other forms of abuse that take place daily – whether it be Darfur, human rights abuses in China (or any country for that matter), female genital mutilation in Africa -- it all makes me sick.

Perhaps the slaughterhouse thing has prompted me to write simply because it is an easy connection to me directly – I go to the grocery store and I buy meat. Call it basic, but it is a direct connection. So when I am hearing (I didn’t want to watch) the report on CBS news this morning about the California slaughterhouse, and the despicable, heart breaking things they did to living animals before they were to die, it effected me.

I had a debate with someone this morning who’s argument was “In the end, the animal is going to die, murder if you will, so what does it matter if it is tortured when it is murdered in the end?” (I am paraphrasing here, but you get the point.) My only reply is this “If you knew you were going to die or even murdered, would you prefer to be tortured first?”

Anyway, instead of smoothing over what took place at the Hallmark Slaughterhouse in California, leaving out the details so as not to upset you, I will share them here:

Sick cows were repeatedly exposed to electric shocks. Fork lifts were used to jab them with prongs and roll them to get them to stand up (mind you, these cows were to too sick to stand up on their own). Even high intensity water sprays (water boarding anyone?) were shot up the animal’s noses.

Why do all this? Simple answer: it is about the bottom line. An animal that cannot stand on its own cannot be slaughtered for market. These tortuous measures might get the animal briefly to stand on its own before it is inspected and then sent to the killing room.

These gruesome practices violate California Law and USDA regulations.

Let’s forget about morality, just for a second though. The scary part is that this meat from this slaughterhouse (Hallmark) is a partner of Westland Meat of Chino. They are a major supplier of beef to the Federal School Lunch Program. So, some “downer” cows (those too sick to stand on their own), who may slip through the system from the torture routine, potentially have a “heightened risk for infections from E. coli, salmonella, and the agent that causes mad-cow disease, which can also cause a brain disease in people”, according to the Seattle Times.

This is just one example of one slaughterhouse. Are there more slaughterhouses that practice the same gruesome torture tactics? Unfortunately, it took an undercover person from an organization outside of the government to bring the video to light. How many slaughter houses are there? We are a society that wants the best price per pound. At what cost?

6 Comments:

At January 31, 2008 at 10:32 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

OMG, I AGREE WITH YOU. I had to turn the channel last night when I saw it on the evening news. I think that there are alot of crzy things going on in our world. Its hard to attempt to wrap our heads around all of it; so yes you have to pick and choose what you can handle. I can say that now that I know this does bother me as well and being highly allergic to alot of veggies products (soy products, and a few more) what am I to do? Turn a blind eye or stop eating beef?
MZ USA (CANT SEEM TO GET THE BLOGGER THING TO WK)

 
At January 31, 2008 at 12:46 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Kim, I love your blog. Your family is just as nutty as mine is. By the way, exactly WHO is this Ben fella? LOL

Tonya
Oxon Hill
(p.s. I watch you every morning Monday - Friday while getting ready for work)

 
At January 31, 2008 at 2:36 PM , Blogger Yota said...

I didn't see it all, but I did see the cow being shoved with the fork lift.

It's nothing new, these practices in mechanised America (and elsewhere) have been going on for half a Century. The meat comes nicely packaged to the store and we buy it without question.

Only recently with the "organic movement" have we been paying higher prices for what we should have been getting all along...

You know, how chickens were treated, before you saw labels like "cage free"? They were in pens and never saw the light of day, the only thing the owners wanted were more EGGS!

What we are talking about here is greed, and a failure to regulate ethic when greed is part of the ingredient in business and profit.

Its at the root of all sins, that and vanity which also is a product of greed (having more)=(pride over those who have less).

I don't hunt because it's too much work, but I have and would more often if I lived in a rural area. I would kill and butcher my own meat, because I'm an omnivore.

When I did hunt I felt like the combined personality of Elmer Fud and Charles Manson. I was very careful about accuracy and deliberate to limit any suffering, but horrified at my success. It was spiritual and moving, but I have the experience and would do it again to feed myself.

We as consumers fail to realise where things come from, we just expect them no questions asked. What goes on to meet the demands of competition has created a holocaust that is unimaginable to us now, but in retrospect, unavoidable.

Food prices are rising and as we place more demands on how that food is delivered? they will rise even more.

When people are hungry, they don't ask questions. Some people do not have that luxury.

We only have ourselves to blame for what we now see. I hope we can change it without too much cost, we must... but there will be a cost.

You don't get sumthin for nuthin...

 
At February 1, 2008 at 3:54 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

The cruelty man is capable of will never stop shocking and disturbing me. The horrendous pain and suffering slaughterhouse animals go through breaks my heart, I'm sobbing over this story, and the thought of the sheer exhaustion and agony these poor helpless creatures go through, at the whim of some twisted human factory worker, for what, to put a buck in his pocket and the luxury of "meat" on someone's plate, just torments my soul. Mankind cannot consider themselves civilized until they stop contributing to animal suffering by creating a demand for animal consumption. It's disgusting. My heart aches for those poor beautiful creatures.

 
At February 1, 2008 at 9:39 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

This brings you back to the way it use to be where everyone raised there own meat which some of us still do , or know someone[neighbor] and do your own slaughtering we know the history of the meat and what it was fed.Its a little more costly but you get what you pay for.
Robbie

 
At February 9, 2008 at 8:30 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree Kim Animals in this condition should never make it to the slaughter house. The USDA is so under staffed of inspectors so stuff like this happens all the time. It is actually an easy fix with say a tax of 2 cents a pound on all meats, that would be enough to pay for the inspectors needed at every slaughter house. But Amarica does not like taxes so that is why this is happening.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home